Charles Butler III
Introduction
Charles Butler III, a longtime resident of the Town of Duanesburg in Schenectady County, New York, was sentenced on October 16, 2026 to twenty-one years in prison followed by twenty-five years of parole for repeatedly sexually abusing a child well known to him. Butler, 47 at sentencing, pleaded guilty on July 15, 2026 to one count of Course of Sexual Conduct Against a Child in the First Degree — a plea he entered on the third day of trial, after jury selection and immediately before opening statements. The abuse he admitted began in the summer of 2009, when he was thirty and his victim was ten years old, and continued until March 2012.
Background Information
The victim first disclosed the abuse to a trusted adult in December 2014 and reported it to the New York State Police the same day, nearly three years after it ended. Investigators from the State Police and Schenectady County Child Protective Services investigated, but the proof available at that time was insufficient to meet the prosecution’s burden at trial — a gap the district attorney’s office attributed to the delayed disclosure common in child sexual abuse cases. The case was never closed. In May 2025, an eyewitness who had been a child when the abuse occurred, and who had not been in a position to testify about it at the time, came forward and cooperated fully; the account corroborated the victim’s report and led to Butler’s arrest. Because of the seriousness of the crime, New York’s statute of limitations does not apply, meaning the charge was never too old to prosecute despite the passage of more than a decade.
The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation
Sentenced after a guilty plea. Butler admitted repeatedly sexually abusing a child from the summer of 2009 until March 2012, beginning when she was ten; a visiting county court judge imposed 21 years in prison plus 25 years of parole on October 16, 2026, after hearing three victim impact statements.
Butler’s plea satisfied a single-count indictment pending against him in Schenectady County Court. He pleaded guilty to repeatedly sexually abusing a child well known to him in the Town of Duanesburg, with the abuse running from the summer of 2009 until March of 2012; he was thirty years old when it began and the child was ten. His courtroom admission, the district attorney noted, confirmed the truth of what the victim reported when she first came forward in 2014.
At sentencing on October 16, 2026, Judge Lorraine K. Diamond, a visiting Schenectady County Court judge, imposed twenty-one years in prison to be followed by twenty-five years of parole after hearing three victim impact statements — one directly from the victim and two from close family members.
Public Reaction and Consequences
District Attorney Robert M. Carney described the case as a betrayal by a trusted adult that left a ten-year-old child with sexual trauma, and singled out the persistence behind the prosecution: “The Schenectady County Special Victims Unit Bureau Chief John Carson never forgot what happened to her and over time developed that proof, presented it to a Grand Jury and was in the process of trying it before a jury when the defendant ended it by admitting his guilt. I am proud that John never waivered in his pursuit of justice and in the witnesses who were willing to come forward and tell their stories in court.”
The case became, in the office’s telling, an example of why delayed-disclosure child abuse cases stay open: the 2014 investigation could not close the gap in proof, and the 2025 eyewitness — someone who had been a child witness himself and only later became able to testify — did.
Current Status
Butler, born November 9, 1978, is serving a twenty-one-year prison term with twenty-five years of parole to follow, imposed October 16, 2026 by visiting Judge Lorraine K. Diamond. The prosecution was handled by Special Victims Bureau Chief John J. Carson and Assistant District Attorney James Faucher; Butler was represented by attorney Mark Juda. The announcement reported no appeal. With the plea entered mid-trial, no jury verdict was ever returned in the case; his admission of guilt at the plea is the adjudication on which the sentence rests.
Impact on Their Career/Life
Butler’s sentence will keep him in prison into his late sixties, with parole supervision extending to 2051 if he serves the full term — a consequence flowing from abuse that ended fourteen years before sentencing, kept alive by a victim who reported it as a teenager, a case file that was never closed, and a witness who came forward as an adult. The district attorney’s account of the sentencing makes the victim’s account the through-line of the case: from her 2014 disclosure, through the years without enough proof, to the impact statements the judge heard before imposing the term.
Sources
- “Charles Butler III Sentenced to 21 Years in Prison on Felony Course of Sexual Conduct Against a Child in the First Degree” — Schenectady County District Attorney’s Office source