David James Gilbert

Introduction

David James Gilbert, 26, of Mansfield, Ohio, a substitute teacher and sports coach in the Madison Local School District, resigned while the district was investigating a grooming allegation involving a 15-year-old high school student — an investigation in which the Richland County Sheriff’s Office identified Gilbert as the suspect . The district immediately placed Gilbert on administrative leave and reported the allegations to law enforcement and to the state Office of Professional Conduct, according to Superintendent Rob Peterson . No criminal charges against Gilbert had been reported as of the coverage, and the account below is drawn from sheriff’s office reports described by the outlet .

Background Information

Gilbert worked in the Madison Local School District as a substitute teacher and as a sports coach . According to the deputy’s report, the student said she met Gilbert at baseball fields where she was working in April, and that the two began texting afterward; she said their conversations turned sexual in July, while Gilbert placed the start of those discussions around June, according to the trooper’s account . The case moved after Ohio State Highway Patrol Trooper Hershey contacted sheriff’s Deputy Caleb Ivy on September 2, following an attempted polygraph examination in which Gilbert discussed his communications with the student .

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Allegations. The claims in this section come from Richland County Sheriff’s Office reports and interviews as described in the reporting on the case. They were never admitted by Gilbert, never criminally charged, and never adjudicated in court. Gilbert denied physical sexual contact to investigators, per the reports, and has not otherwise publicly responded to the allegations.

According to the trooper’s account, Gilbert said he and the student had talked about waiting until she turned 18 to have sex; Gilbert denied any physical sexual contact and said the two had never exchanged nude images . The student told investigators she sent Gilbert clothed selfies, including some taken while she was at school, and that he sometimes reacted with a heart or told her she looked nice . She said their conversations included discussions of sexual activity, and that Gilbert sometimes laughed or replied, “If the stars align” . According to the trooper, Gilbert said he had masturbated while looking at the clothed photos the student sent him, and reported discussing sexual topics with about 25 students since he turned 18 . After the attempted polygraph, the student told investigators, she and Gilbert spoke over FaceTime; she said he appeared scared and told her the examination had gone poorly and that investigators knew about their communications . Asked whether she thought they were in a relationship, she said it felt like one and that she believed they both saw it that way, describing them as good friends .

Public Reaction and Consequences

Superintendent Rob Peterson, in an email response to the outlet, said: “We have high expectations and standards for the professional conduct of all of our employees, especially when the conduct involves one of our students” . “When we receive allegations of misconduct, we take those allegations seriously, investigate them thoroughly, and when warranted, report them to law enforcement and the Office of Professional Conduct as we did in this instance,” he wrote . Gilbert resigned while the investigation was underway . Investigators continued building the file after the resignation: the student’s parents consented to a search of her phone, the sheriff’s office copied its data on September 10 and made it available to Detective Garrett Nedrow the following day, and Deputy Ivy and Detective Nedrow also went to Gilbert’s home on September 3 to speak with him — he was away when they arrived .

Current Status

Gilbert has resigned from the Madison Local School District and his conduct remains under investigation by the Richland County Sheriff’s Office; no charges had been announced in the reporting . The district reported the allegations to both law enforcement and the state Office of Professional Conduct, meaning his license status can be reviewed separately from any criminal outcome . The reporting does not state whether Gilbert has obtained other education work since his resignation .

Impact on Their Career/Life

At 26, Gilbert’s education career — substitute teaching and coaching in the same district — ended with a resignation mid-investigation, a sheriff’s office file describing sexualized messaging with a 15-year-old student, and a state professional-conduct referral that can follow his teaching license regardless of what the criminal investigation produces . The detail from the reports that he claimed to have discussed sexual topics with roughly 25 students since turning 18, if pursued by investigators, suggests the case could widen beyond the single complainant whose phone was searched with her parents’ consent .

Sources

  • Ashland County Pictures (ACP News), “Madison Substitute Teacher/Sports Coach Resigned During Grooming Investigation,” November 13, 2026 — source
Page updated: November 13, 2026