Frantzson Saintilien

Introduction

Frantzson Saintilien, 65, of Elmont, Long Island, was convicted on October 9, 2026, on all 18 counts of an indictment charging him with preparing false tax returns for clients — returns containing fictitious fuel expenses, fictitious business expenses and losses, and fraudulent tax credits that improperly reduced his clients’ tax liability . The verdict came after a one-week trial before United States District Judge Brian M. Cogan in federal court in Brooklyn . When sentenced, Saintilien faces up to 54 years in prison and financial penalties .

Background Information

The charges arose from Saintilien’s role as a tax preparer at his multi-service business located at One Elmont Road in Elmont, New York . As proved at trial, between 2019 and 2023 — for the tax years 2018 through 2022 — Saintilien prepared false and fraudulent Forms 1040 and associated schedules for his clients containing a range of fabricated claims . Those included that his clients had paid federal taxes on nontaxable uses of fuel on Form 4136, had incurred losses from the sale of assets on Form 4797, and had incurred business expenses on Schedule C .

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Convicted; awaiting sentencing. A federal jury convicted Saintilien on all 18 counts after a one-week trial. He has not yet been sentenced, and faces up to 54 years in prison when he is.

As a result of the false claims, the IRS issued larger refunds to Saintilien’s clients than they were in fact owed . In many cases, prosecutors proved, Saintilien diverted funds from those improper refunds to himself without his clients’ knowledge . Based on the fraudulent returns charged in the indictment alone, his conduct resulted in a loss of more than $100,000 to the IRS; the government estimates his scheme cost the government well in excess of one million dollars in total . The case carries docket number 24-CR-391 in the Eastern District of New York .

Public Reaction and Consequences

“The defendant is a serial fraudster who was masquerading as a tax preparer, but instead of performing an important service, he victimized clients who trusted him and willfully stole government funds from the IRS,” United States Attorney Joseph Nocella, Jr. said after the verdict . “With today’s verdict, Saintilien has been held accountable for his conduct and will face the consequences” . IRS Criminal Investigation’s New York Special Agent in Charge, Harry T. Chavis, Jr., said the verdict reaffirmed the agency’s commitment to holding dishonest return preparers accountable: “those who undermine the integrity of the tax system by facilitating the filing of false tax returns with egregiously fraudulent credits will be held responsible for their actions” .

Current Status

Saintilien has not yet been sentenced; the verdict on all 18 counts leaves him facing up to 54 years in prison and financial penalties at sentencing . The conviction is final as a jury verdict but remains subject to post-trial motions and appeal, and no sentencing date was announced in the government’s release . The case is being prosecuted by the Office’s General Crimes Section, with Assistant United States Attorneys Rebecca Ann Sussman, Amanda Muros-Bishoff and Joshua B. Dugan in charge of the prosecution .

Impact on Their Career/Life

A tax-preparation business that served the Elmont community for years is now the documented vehicle for an 18-count federal fraud conviction, with prosecutors describing its owner as a “serial fraudster” who victimized the very clients whose returns he filed . The proof at trial that he siphoned improper refund money from clients without their knowledge adds a breach-of-trust dimension beyond the theft from the Treasury itself — the fraud hit both the government that paid the refunds and the customers who trusted him to file honestly . At 65, Saintilien faces a sentencing exposure of up to 54 years that, even at the low end of any guideline range, will consume the remainder of his working life and retirement .

Sources

  • U.S. Attorney’s Office, Eastern District of New York (DOJ), “Long Island Tax Preparer Convicted of Defrauding The Internal Revenue Service,” October 9, 2026 — source
Page updated: October 9, 2026