Brenna Butdorf

Introduction

Brenna Butdorf of Wooster, Ohio, was sentenced to 18 months in federal prison, followed by three years of supervised release, for failing to turn over employment taxes she withheld from her husband’s company’s workers. The Internal Revenue Service announced the sentence out of Akron on November 9, 2026, saying Butdorf pleaded guilty to Failing to Truthfully Account for and Pay Over Trust Fund Taxes.

Background Information

Butdorf managed the finances of an electrical contracting company that her husband owned and that operated out of their home, serving as its accountant and office manager. In that role she withheld social security, Medicare, and federal income taxes from the company’s employees’ paychecks — money that federal law requires such companies to collect and then remit to the United States.

Instead of remitting the withheld funds, Butdorf issued payments to herself and her husband that were funded by the unremitted withholdings. From 2015 to 2021 — a window that begins before 2021 — investigators found she failed to pay more than $494,000 in employment taxes to the government.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Convicted and sentenced. Butdorf pleaded guilty to failing to truthfully account for and pay over trust-fund taxes and received an 18-month federal prison sentence.

Employment-tax withholding is what prosecutors call trust money: it belongs to the government from the moment it is deducted, and an employer who keeps it is taking funds held in trust for workers and the Treasury. Court documents cited by the IRS say that is precisely what Butdorf did at the family company — quarterly payment obligations went unmet while the withheld cash paid for other things.

The personal spending was specific. Butdorf spent the proceeds on herself and her family, including purchasing a condominium in Florida and paying dues for a private camp and a shooting club, along with vacations. The plea to failing to truthfully account for and pay over trust-fund taxes covered the withholding she kept, and the court responded with custody rather than a purely financial sanction.

Public Reaction and Consequences

The sentence is 18 months in federal prison plus three years of supervised release — a custodial outcome for a bookkeeping role that prosecutors treated as a six-year conversion of worker withholdings. The workers whose paychecks funded the scheme had their taxes withheld either way; the unpaid balances remained owed to the government.

The IRS release does not state whether the taxes were ultimately repaid, whether her husband was charged, or whether Butdorf has made a public statement. What the record shows is the plea, the $494,000-plus shortfall, and the prison term imposed in November 2026.

Current Status

Butdorf was sentenced to 18 months in prison and three years of supervised release following her guilty plea to failing to truthfully account for and pay over trust-fund taxes. The conduct at issue ran from 2015 to 2021 at the home-based electrical contracting business she managed for her husband.

Impact on Their Career/Life

The accounting and office-manager role through which Butdorf handled the company’s finances is the same role that produced her conviction: she was the person who withheld the taxes and the person who decided they would not be paid over. An 18-month federal sentence for trust-fund tax fraud now stands in place of that career.

Sources

  • IRS Criminal Investigation, November 9, “Ohio woman sentenced for not paying employment taxes,” 2026 — source
Page updated: November 9, 2026