Rodney Hinton Jr.

Introduction

Rodney Hinton Jr. was sentenced on November 16, 2026 to 15 years to life in prison — Ohio’s mandatory sentence for murder — for the death of Hamilton County Sheriff’s Deputy Larry Henderson, who was struck and killed by a vehicle on May 2, 2025 while directing traffic near the University of Cincinnati’s graduation. Judge Jody Luebbers ordered the term served consecutive to an 18-month sentence Hinton received in Clermont County for assaulting corrections officers.

Background Information

The killing happened one day after Hinton’s son, Ryan, was fatally shot by Cincinnati police. Hinton stood accused of intentionally driving into Deputy Henderson on May 2, 2025, while the 15-year veteran was directing traffic for the University of Cincinnati’s graduation ceremony. At trial, the defense argued Hinton was in a mental health crisis when he hit Henderson, because he had just watched video of police shooting and killing his son; prosecutors maintained he was grieving and angry but understood his actions were wrong.

The trial lasted just under two weeks, with opening statements on October 7, 2026 and jury deliberations beginning October 20. Hinton did not testify, as he had no obligation to. Jurors did not hear a recorded police interrogation of Hinton or see body-camera video of officers’ initial contact with him — instead, they heard three psychologists recount statements from their evaluations of him. Local attorney Jay Clark, following the trial, called the absence of the recorded interrogation very uncommon.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Convicted and sentenced. A jury convicted Hinton of murder, and the court imposed Ohio’s mandatory 15-years-to-life term for murder; an appeal alleging juror misconduct has been filed.

On October 23, 2026, as jurors entered a third day of deliberations, the jury found Hinton guilty of murder, two counts of reckless homicide and two counts of felonious assault, with a finding that Henderson was a peace officer at the time of the offense on the assault counts. The reckless-homicide counts were lesser charges allowed in place of the aggravated-murder counts he had faced.

The insanity question was the center of the trial. The psychologists who evaluated Hinton agreed he has a serious mental illness; they disagreed on whether it prevented him from understanding the wrongfulness of his actions. The defense’s expert testified Hinton did not know right from wrong at the time of the crash, while the state’s rebuttal witnesses testified he was grieving, angry and in extreme emotional pain but still knew his actions were wrong.

After the verdict, Juror No. 2 made a statement raising the question of whether jurors took into consideration statements Hinton made to a psychologist when deciding guilt — something the jury had been specifically instructed not to do. Lead defense attorney Clyde Bennett filed an appeal seeking a new trial over the alleged juror misconduct and wanted to subpoena jurors to question them; prosecutors argued the request relied on hearsay. Judge Luebbers denied the motion for a new trial, denied the juror subpoenas, and denied a second motion for acquittal and a new trial.

Public Reaction and Consequences

Before sentencing, Henderson’s family addressed the court. His wife, Lori Henderson, described him as loving, funny and a protector: “I do not get to ask my husband how his day is or what he would like for dinner or where we’re going on our next date night.” His daughter Adrianna remembered a father who came to his children’s sporting events in uniform — “He always showed up” — and recalled saying goodbye at his visitation: “I hugged my dad’s body for the last time. I held his hands as tightly as I could, wishing and praying he could grasp mine back.” A statement from another daughter, Alexandria, read by Adrianna, said he “had spent his life showing up for other people. He deserved to come home.”

Hamilton County Prosecutor Connie Pillich acknowledged the impact on both families and the community: “This case involved tragedy upon tragedy, and it has affected our entire community. I hope that the convictions and the sentence can bring some kind of finality.” Defense attorney Bennett said he was not surprised by the sentence, which preserved Hinton’s life after the death penalty and life without parole were taken off the table, and said Hinton — whom he described as having a mental illness to this day — is remorseful but had been counseled not to speak.

Current Status

Hinton is serving 15 years to life for murder, consecutive to an 18-month Clermont County sentence for assaulting corrections officers. His appeal over the alleged juror misconduct has been filed; the Ohio appellate process will determine whether the conviction stands.

Impact on Their Career/Life

Hinton’s life now carries a murder conviction with a maximum-term structure that keeps him in prison for at least 15 years, on top of the corrections-officer assault term, with the appeal as the only open path. The case — a deputy killed the day after the defendant’s son was shot by police — became one of the most closely watched Cincinnati prosecutions of 2026, and Judge Luebbers’s courtroom heard both the Henderson family’s loss and the mental-illness dispute that will follow Hinton into the appeal.

Sources

  • WLWT (NBC Cincinnati), “Rodney Hinton Jr. sentenced to 15 years to life for deputy’s murder,” November 16, 2026 — source
Page updated: May 2, 2025