Lester Everly II
Introduction
Lester Eugene Everly II, 47, is a teacher at Albert Gallatin High School in Fayette County, Pennsylvania, who was arrested over the weekend of November 14-15, 2026 on charges connected to the sexual exploitation of minors after, according to Fayette County District Attorney Michael Aubele, he arranged to meet up and pay for sex with someone he believed was a 15-year-old girl. The case was an undercover sting: a police officer posed as a person offering access to a 15-year-old child for $170, and Everly was taken into custody when he traveled to the meeting location in South Union Township. The district attorney stressed the alleged conduct did not involve an Albert Gallatin student, but Everly — a 17-year district employee with no prior complaints on record — has been relieved of all duties and barred from district property should he be released. He is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.
Background Information
Everly had been employed with the Albert Gallatin Area School District for approximately 17 years, according to Interim Superintendent Dr. Jason Hutchinson, who told the school board the district has no record of any complaints involving him during that time. The arrest was carried out as part of an undercover operation run jointly by the Pennsylvania State Police Uniontown Criminal Investigation Unit and the PSP Bureau of Criminal Investigation Computer Crime Unit. Fayette County prosecutors said the case marks the third recent arrest of a Fayette County teacher for alleged sexual misconduct with minors, amid a string of school-employee cases that has also included a separate child-pornography arrest over the same weekend.
The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation
Charged, not convicted. Everly faces charges from an undercover child-exploitation sting. He has not been tried, and the accusations — including his reported confession to investigators — are allegations within a pending criminal case.
According to District Attorney Aubele, Everly believed he was communicating with an adult who had a girlfriend with a 15-year-old child that he was going to offer for sex for $170. “Our police officer was posing as a person who had a girlfriend who had a 15-year-old child that he could make available for $170. So the defendant traveled to this location, South Union Township, brought other things that he was asked to bring with him, that he would need for sexual activity. We were able to confirm that this was the individual that we believed we were speaking to online,” Aubele said. Police arrested Everly at the agreed-upon location when he arrived with money and a condom.
According to the criminal complaint, after being taken into custody in South Union Township, police say Everly confessed to bringing a condom and $180 to the meetup location. Aubele called it “very concerning” whenever somebody who works with children is alleged to have targeted a child for sexual activity, while noting that authorities say the charges do not stem from Everly’s involvement at Albert Gallatin High School — though his role as a teacher is part of the investigation. No student is alleged to have been involved in the conduct underlying the charges.
Public Reaction and Consequences
The school district’s response was immediate. In a statement, Interim Superintendent Hutchinson said Albert Gallatin had been informed of the arrest of a staff member “last evening,” that student safety is the district’s primary concern, and that the district is cooperating with law enforcement. He addressed the matter at a school board work session on Monday night, telling the board the incident did not involve a student. “The employee has been relieved of all duties. Should the employee be released from custody, the teacher will not be permitted on any district property,” Hutchinson said. The case landed on a community already shaken: prosecutors say it is the third recent arrest of a Fayette County teacher for alleged sexual misconduct with minors, and police separately arrested a 57-year-old man over the same weekend after finding child pornography on his personal devices.
Current Status
Everly has been charged following his weekend arrest; the specific counts he faces were described in coverage as charges connected to the sexual exploitation of minors. He was in custody as of the district’s Monday-night statement, which anticipated his possible release on conditions barring him from district property. He has not been arraigned into a trial schedule in the available reporting, no conviction has been entered, and every allegation — including the reported confession — is subject to the presumption of innocence. The district has relieved him of all duties pending the case.
Impact on Their Career/Life
Seventeen years of employment at Albert Gallatin High School ended within a day of the sting arrest: Everly was relieved of all duties, barred from returning to any district property even on release from custody, and named by the district attorney as a case “very concerning” in a county experiencing a cluster of teacher sexual-misconduct arrests. Whatever the outcome of the criminal case, the district’s statement that it has “no record of any complaints involving this individual” now sits alongside the allegation that he traveled to a meeting he believed would provide a 15-year-old child for paid sex, carrying a condom and cash.