Mason Maguire

Introduction

Mason Maguire, 26, of Centereach, New York, is an emergency medical technician with the Farmingville Fire Department who was indicted on November 5, 2026 on first-degree sexual abuse, forcible touching and second-degree unlawful imprisonment charges for allegedly sexually abusing a female co-worker inside the firehouse during her shift on July 4, 2026. Prosecutors say Maguire arrived at the Suffolk County firehouse at 12:27 a.m. despite not being scheduled to work, forcibly abused the co-worker, and then prevented her from leaving by grabbing her arms, twisting them behind her back and physically restraining her. He had been arrested days after the incident on a misdemeanor charge; the grand jury indictment added the felony counts. He has not been convicted, and the charges are allegations.

Background Information

Maguire served as an EMT with the Farmingville Fire Department, a fire department on Horseblock Road in Suffolk County, Long Island. According to prosecutors, the alleged assault took place inside the firehouse while the victim was on shift, in the early hours of July 4, 2026 — a holiday night — when Maguire arrived at approximately 12:27 a.m. without being scheduled to work. Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney’s Public Corruption Bureau investigated further after the initial arrest, and detectives from the Suffolk County Police Department worked the case with the bureau’s Public Corruption Squad, work that produced the grand jury indictment with escalated charges.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Indicted; presumption of innocence. Maguire faces felony counts from a grand jury indictment. He has not been tried, and the account of the July 4 incident is the prosecution’s allegation.

According to prosecutors, Maguire allegedly forcibly sexually abused a female co-worker while inside the firehouse. Authorities said the victim attempted to leave the room immediately afterward, but Maguire allegedly prevented her escape by grabbing her arms, twisting them behind her back and physically restraining her. Tierney framed the case around the trust attached to first-responder roles: “The badge and uniform of a first responder are symbols of trust, service and protection – not a shield for sexual abuse,” and “This defendant is accused of violating a coworker in the very place where she should have been able to feel safe.” Maguire was initially arrested July 8, 2026 on a misdemeanor charge; following additional investigation by the District Attorney’s Public Corruption Bureau, prosecutors secured a grand jury indictment containing the additional felony counts.

Maguire was arraigned on the indictment on November 5, 2026 before Acting Supreme Court Justice Karen M. Wilutis, who set bail at $10,000 cash, $30,000 bond or $100,000 partially secured bond. If convicted of the top charge — a class D violent felony — Maguire faces up to seven years in prison and sex offender registration requirements. He is represented by attorney Paul Seres and is scheduled to return to court on November 25, 2026. Assistant District Attorney Tara K. O’Donnell of the Public Corruption Bureau is prosecuting the case.

Public Reaction and Consequences

The district attorney’s announcement put the case before the public with an explicit condemnation of abuse within a firehouse: Tierney’s statement that a uniform is “not a shield for sexual abuse” and his description of the firehouse as the place a co-worker “should have been able to feel safe” framed the indictment as a breach of first-responder trust rather than a private dispute. The case moved up the criminal ladder — from the July 8 misdemeanor arrest to a felony indictment carrying sex-offender registration exposure — after the Public Corruption Bureau’s additional investigation, a progression prosecutors chose to announce. The South Shore Press reported that the charges are allegations and Maguire is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. No statement from Maguire or his attorney on the allegations appears in the available reporting.

Current Status

Maguire has been arraigned on an indictment charging first-degree sexual abuse, forcible touching and second-degree unlawful imprisonment, with bail set at $10,000 cash, $30,000 bond or $100,000 partially secured bond, and a court return scheduled for November 25, 2026. The charges are unproven allegations: no trial has occurred, no conviction has been entered, and the felony counts remain subject to the presumption of innocence. The original July misdemeanor arrest now sits beneath the grand jury indictment’s added felony counts.

Impact on Their Career/Life

An EMT who answered calls for the Farmingville Fire Department now faces a class D violent felony that carries prison exposure of up to seven years and mandatory sex-offender registration if proven, with his bail conditions and a November court return structuring his life while the case proceeds. The alleged conduct — an off-shift arrival at a firehouse where a co-worker was working, an alleged assault, and an alleged physical blocking of her exit — has been publicly characterized by the county’s top prosecutor as a violation of the trust symbolized by the uniform he wore, a characterization that outlasts any bail schedule in a volunteer fire service built on standing in the community.

Sources

  • “Farmingville Fire Department EMT Indicted on Sexual Abuse Charges” — The South Shore Press source
Page updated: November 5, 2026