Mark Hunt

Introduction

Mark Hunt is West Virginia’s State Auditor, a statewide elected official now facing a federal indictment that alleges he and members of his staff ran a scheme to steer delinquent property-tax deeds to a friend’s real estate company. U.S. Attorney Moore Capito of the Southern District of West Virginia announced the indictment on Monday, November 16, 2026. The charges are allegations in an indictment, not convictions: Hunt is presumed innocent, and he has said publicly that he is innocent and will defend himself.

Background Information

Hunt holds an office on West Virginia’s Board of Public Works whose Land Division handles delinquent property tax lands; by law, such deeds are supposed to be signed by the deputy commissioner of delinquent and nonentered lands, not by the auditor. The federal investigation into his office began last year and involved the FBI and the West Virginia Legislature’s Commission on Special Investigations.

The charges stem from nine delinquent property tax deeds signed personally by Hunt on behalf of MAPA Inc., a real estate company owned by Patricia Johns, the wife of Charleston attorney Robert Johns — a friend and business associate of Hunt who also worked briefly last year as a special counsel in the State Auditor’s Office, according to federal investigators. Documents obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request and previously reported by West Virginia Watch show Hunt signed the deeds last year on MAPA’s behalf.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Indicted; presumption of innocence.

A federal grand jury indicted Hunt alongside Robert Johns, Deputy Chief of Staff David Keith Cole, General Counsel Frederick Scott Caudill and State Auditor’s Office employee Marie Ann Hoffman. Hunt, Johns, Cole and Caudill each face nine counts of theft of property, while Caudill and Cole each face an additional count of making materially false statements to federal investigators. Hunt, Cole and Hoffman were also indicted on charges of bank fraud.

According to the indictments, State Auditor’s Office staff within the Land Division advised Hunt that the property deeds could not legally be executed on behalf of Johns, because required payments by MAPA had not been made and the 120-day statutory deadline had been missed. All nine deeds were executed past the 120-day statutory window mandated by West Virginia code and without a circuit court order, and they were signed by Hunt personally rather than by the deputy commissioner of delinquent and nonentered lands. Hunt ignored this advice and signed the deeds over to MAPA anyway, aided and abetted by Caudill and Cole, court documents say.

“Career employees of the Auditor’s Office had determined that the purchaser failed to meet the requirements under West Virginia law and was not entitled to receive those deeds,” Capito said. “However, according to the indictment, Mr. Hunt overruled those employees and personally signed and issued all nine of those deeds.” Capito said these actions amounted to a theft of property from the original landowners.

One of the nine properties MAPA purchased had been owned by NAJ LLC, an entity listing Robert L. Johns as a member and organizer — also, per the indictment, in violation of state code. The indictment alleges that both Caudill and Cole lied to FBI agents, and accuses Caudill of asking State Auditor’s Office employees “who will be the whistleblower” regarding the nine deeds. Hoffman is accused of a timecard scheme — leaving work on Friday afternoons to perform private work for Hunt’s law practice while on state time, defrauding taxpayers — aided and abetted by Cole.

Public Reaction and Consequences

Announcing the indictment at a press conference at the Robert C. Byrd Federal Courthouse in Charleston, Capito called it “a somber day for West Virginia” and said, “The rules governing public office are not optional. They do not change based on who you know, who your friends are or what position you hold… As alleged, the state auditor violated that trust.”

Calls for Hunt’s resignation came from State Treasurer Larry Pack and both the West Virginia Democratic and Republican parties. Del. Josh Holstein, the GOP chairman, said the charges say “Mark Hunt used the power of that office to take property from West Virginia families” and that Hunt “should resign today.” Del. Mike Pushkin, the Democratic chairman, said Hunt, Cole, Caudill, Hoffman and Johns should resign their public positions immediately. House Speaker Roger Hanshaw called on Hunt to resign or face possible impeachment proceedings, warning the House would “take swift action in January” if he did not.

Hunt, in a social media statement, said, “I am innocent of these charges. This indictment is an insult to the principles on which this country was founded. I am presumed innocent and will vigorously defend myself against these charges.” He added, “I remain focused on the work of the Auditor’s Office and will continue to serve the people of West Virginia while this matter is resolved in court.” A request for comment from the State Auditor’s Office was not returned.

Current Status

No arrest warrants were issued; Capito said those indicted would be self-reporting to federal authorities. Hunt remains in office while the case proceeds, but if the House of Delegates adopts impeachment articles, the state Senate would determine whether to convict and remove him. The last impeachment of a Board of Public Works member by the Legislature came in 1988, when State Treasurer A. James Manchin resigned ahead of his Senate impeachment trial.

Impact on Their Career/Life

The indictment has placed a sitting statewide officeholder in the dock of a federal prosecution while he continues to hold the auditor’s office, with impeachment threatened and leaders of both parties demanding his resignation. Separately, West Virginia Watch reported that a used car dealership Hunt started months before taking office, on property owned by Johns’ NAJ company, recently shut down. The nine theft counts and the bank fraud charge against him are allegations that have yet to be tested in court, where Hunt — by his own account and by law — is presumed innocent.

Sources

  • The Intermountain, “Grand jury indicts Hunt, staff members,” November 18, 2026. source
Page updated: November 16, 2026