Rebecca Gutierrez

Introduction

Rebecca Gutierrez is the former office manager of Hastings and Havlik Dentistry, a dental practice in Mattoon, Illinois. After pleading guilty to five counts of wire fraud, she was sentenced on November 16, 2026, to 27 months in federal prison for taking roughly $900,000 from her employer over the course of five years.

The case was heard in the United States District Court for the Central District of Illinois, where Chief Judge Stirling Bruce described the theft as a “massive abuse of trust.”

Background Information

Gutierrez held the office manager position at Hastings and Havlik Dentistry in Mattoon, a role that gave her access to the practice’s money. According to a criminal complaint, she took money from the business and transferred it to her personal account around one to five times a month, continuing the pattern for approximately five years.

The complaint stated that she used the diverted funds to pay off her credit card debt while writing the payments off as a company expense, disguising the transfers inside the dental office’s ordinary bookkeeping. By the time the scheme ended, the total taken from the Mattoon practice was approximately $900,000 — money that WTHI reported went toward her personal credit card bills rather than the business.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Convicted and sentenced.

Gutierrez pleaded guilty to five counts of wire fraud. At her sentencing hearing on November 16, 2026, Chief Judge Stirling Bruce called the theft a “massive abuse of trust,” a pointed characterization of an employee stealing from the small practice that employed her.

Gutierrez addressed the court directly. “Dr. Hastings, his staff and family did not deserve this,” she said during the sentencing. “And I hope they understand how deeply sorry I am.”

“I’m determined to prove I can be a better person and I’m hoping I can make something positive out of this difficult part of my life,” she told the court.

Both the prosecution and the defense recommended the same outcome: a sentence of 27 months, followed by three years of supervised release and full restitution paid to the victims. Gutierrez was sentenced on those terms.

Her defense attorney, Anthony Bruno, said Gutierrez “decided to come clean to her boss and take this on the chin, and that’s exactly what she ended up doing.” He added that “she’s made more than half of her restitution payments already. She’s ready to do her punishment, do her time, and return to society as a new person, and be a contributing member of the public.”

Public Reaction and Consequences

The consequence of the plea was a 27-month federal prison sentence arrived at jointly: prosecutors and the defense stood together on the recommendation of 27 months, three years of supervised release and full restitution, and the court imposed it.

By the time of sentencing, Gutierrez had agreed to liquidate her assets and had already paid $500,000 in restitution — more than half of what she owed, according to her attorney.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Eugene Miller told News 10 that imposing prison time is important to deter others in similar positions from committing the same crime, framing the sentence as a message to employees entrusted with an employer’s finances.

Current Status

Gutierrez is serving the 27-month prison term imposed on November 16, 2026, in the Central District of Illinois, to be followed by three years of supervised release.

The judgment requires full restitution to the victims. She has already paid $500,000 of that amount after liquidating her assets, with the remainder still owed under the sentence.

Impact on Their Career/Life

The wire fraud conviction and prison term ended Gutierrez’s run as the office manager of the practice she stole from, and she now faces roughly two years in federal custody followed by three years under supervision.

Her attorney told the court she is ready to serve the sentence and return to society as a contributing member of the public, and Gutierrez herself said she is determined to prove she can be a better person and to make something positive out of the difficult period ahead — remarks that followed thefts she admitted carrying out as often as five times in a single month.

Sources

  • WTHI, “Coles County woman sentenced to federal prison for stealing $900,000 from dental office,” Nov. 16, 2026. source
Page updated: November 16, 2026