Mary and Gwenn Fitzmaurice
Booked on murder and accessory charges. A 45-year-old California woman and her 75-year-old mother were arrested Nov. 17, 2026, four years after the daughter’s father was killed and his severed head was found in a trash bag near Foresthill. Placer County investigators say Mary Fitzmaurice killed Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr. at the family’s Citrus Heights home in 2022 and that she and Gwenn — his wife — worked together to dispose of the remains, all while collecting his Social Security and pension payments behind a story that he was still alive. Both charges are accusations in an open investigation; neither has been adjudicated.
Introduction
Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, and her mother Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, of Citrus Heights, California, were booked into the South Placer Jail on Nov. 17, 2026 — Mary on a murder charge, Gwenn as an accessory — in the killing of Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., the husband and father they lived with until his death in 2022. The case stayed cold for more than four years because the victim had never been reported missing: the only part of him ever found was his severed head, discovered in a trash bag on Sept. 28, 2022 in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill, and decomposition left investigators unable to identify it. Identification finally came through forensic genetic genealogy — DNA testing at a Texas lab pointed to distant relatives, and FBI-assisted comparison samples confirmed the head belonged to Paul Fitzmaurice Jr. Sheriff’s officials announced the arrests on Wednesday, Nov. 18, saying the two women had “kept up the facade that Paul was alive” while receiving his Social Security benefits and his pension.
Background Information
Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr. was 73 at the time of the 2022 killing and had been living in Citrus Heights with his wife, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, and their 45-year-old daughter, Mary, at the family’s home on Lichen Drive. He was never reported missing — a fact investigators say explains why years of searches of missing-persons databases turned up nothing. The discovery that broke the case open came on Sept. 28, 2022, when a resident walking her dog in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill, in Placer County’s Sierra foothills, found a human head inside a trash bag, with the massive Mosquito Fire burning through the same area at the time.
The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation
Open case, unadjudicated. The account below comes from the Placer County Sheriff’s Office’s announcements and from news reporting on them. Mary and Gwenn Fitzmaurice have been booked, not tried; no motive has been stated and no conviction exists.
The identification effort moved in stages: forensic experts at California State University, Chico built a preliminary age and race profile from the skull and produced an artist’s rendering, and the victim’s DNA was entered into the national CODIS database, which returned no matches. In January 2024 investigators sent the DNA to Othram Labs in Texas for forensic genetic genealogy testing, a technique that builds a family tree from a DNA profile to find relatives. Othram’s work surfaced possible distant relatives, and FBI agents interviewed them and collected comparison DNA samples, leading investigators to identify the remains as Paul Fitzmaurice Jr. Detectives then learned he had last been known to live with his wife and daughter on Lichen Drive — the people who, investigators allege, had killed him and hidden the fact.
On Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, Placer County sheriff’s detectives served a search warrant at the Citrus Heights home and arrested both women that day. Investigators believe Mary was responsible for Paul’s murder at that home, and that Gwenn helped dispose of his remains; the sheriff’s office said the two worked together to get rid of the body. Sheriff Wayne Woo said the wife and daughter had “kept up the facade that Paul was alive” — collecting his Social Security benefits and his pension after his death. Officials said more charges may be coming, that no motive is known, and that no remains beyond Paul’s head have ever been located. The FBI, Citrus Heights Police Department, Contra Costa County Crime Lab and the Placer County Cold Case Foundation assisted in the investigation.
Public Reaction and Consequences
The sheriff’s office announcement made local news first, with KCRA and CBS Sacramento detailing the four-year forensic effort, and the New York Post carried the case nationally the same day under its “grisly horror movie discovery” framing — a severed head found by a dog-walker in fire country. The detail that drew the most attention was financial: the accusation that the two women collected a dead man’s Social Security and pension while reporting nothing, a benefit-fraud layer that officials signaled could bring further charges. The case also gave Othram-style genetic genealogy another headline success after CODIS, composite renderings and age profiles had all failed — the same lab-assisted approach that has broken dozens of decades-old cases — this time identifying a man whose own family never reported him gone.
Current Status
Mary Fitzmaurice has been booked on a murder charge and Gwenn Fitzmaurice on accessory charges; both were in the South Placer Jail as of the announcements, and prosecutors said more charges may be coming. The investigation remains active, no motive has been disclosed, and the rest of Paul Fitzmaurice Jr.’s remains have not been found. No arraignment outcomes or pleas had been reported at the time of the announcements, and every allegation — the murder, the disposal of remains, the benefits collected — is an accusation by investigators, not an adjudicated finding.
Impact on Their Career/Life
Two women in their mid-seventies and mid-forties who had lived quietly at a Citrus Heights address for four years are now booked into county jail on a killing the neighborhood likely never knew had happened — Paul Fitzmaurice Jr.’s disappearance was never reported by anyone, including the people who lived with him. If investigators’ account holds up in court, a family’s private arrangement — collecting a dead man’s benefits behind a maintained fiction — becomes the aggravating story layered on top of a homicide. For Placer County, the arrest closes the identification phase of a case that began with a bag in the Todd Valley brush in 2022 and turned on commercial forensic genealogy four years later; the pending question officials flagged is what additional charges the benefits and the missing remains might bring.
Sources
- New York Post, “Sacramento mother and daughter arrested in killing of Citrus Heights man” (Nov. 18, 2026) — source
- KCRA 3, “Wife and daughter arrested for 2022 murder after man’s severed head found in Foresthill” (Nov. 18, 2026) — source
- CBS News Sacramento, “Foresthill cold case breakthrough leads to arrests of victim’s wife, daughter more than 4 years later” (Nov. 18, 2026) — source
- X post, @nypost, Nov. 18, 2026 — source