Jeffrey Lentz

Jeffrey Lentz

Pleaded guilty; awaiting sentencing. Jeffrey Lentz, 57, of Toms River, New Jersey, pleaded guilty on Nov. 16, 2026 to second-degree possession of a weapon for an unlawful purpose and third-degree animal cruelty for fatally shooting Ruby, his stepdaughter’s 1-year-old French bulldog, in the face while dog-sitting her on Oct. 3, 2025. He admitted in court that he pointed the gun at the puppy intending only to startle her — and that a round went off and killed her. Prosecutors will seek five years in state prison with a year of parole ineligibility, a concurrent three-year term on the animal cruelty count, and a lifetime ban on owning animals when he is sentenced on Jan. 22, 2027.

Introduction

Jeffrey Lentz is a 57-year-old Toms River man — the husband of dog owner Nicole Guarino’s mother, and the stepfather figure the family trusted with their French bulldog — who admitted in an Ocean County courtroom in November 2026 that he shot and killed Ruby, the family’s 1-year-old puppy, while she was in his care. Ruby died on Oct. 3, 2025, during the first time the family had ever left her with Lentz and his wife for an overnight stay, and the shooting stayed hidden for a month: the family was told the puppy had been attacked by another animal, until a necropsy found a gunshot wound to her face and an X-ray showed a bullet lodged in her jawbone. Lentz was arrested a month after the death and pleaded guilty on Nov. 16, 2026 to possession of a weapon for an unlawful purpose and animal cruelty, with prosecutors now seeking a five-year prison sentence and what the Ocean County Prosecutor’s Office calls a lifetime ban from owning animals.

Background Information

Lentz lives in Toms River, New Jersey, and is the stepfather of Ruby’s owner, Nicole Guarino — he and his wife, Guarino’s mother, were the couple the family turned to when they needed someone to watch the dog. On Oct. 3, 2025, Guarino’s husband dropped Ruby off at the home on Lyford Court in Berkeley Township where Lentz lived with Guarino’s mother while she and her husband went to a wedding — the first sleepover Ruby had ever spent there. According to the affidavit of probable cause cited in court coverage, Guarino’s husband told detectives that when he arrived that afternoon, Lentz was pouring himself a Tito’s vodka with a small handgun in a red holster on his hip. Hours later, at about 9:05 p.m., Berkeley Township police responded to the home for an animal call and learned the dog left in Lentz’s care had died from her injury.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Admitted conduct; conviction entered. Unlike most entries here, the account below comes in significant part from Lentz’s own sworn plea answers. His guilty plea is a conviction; what remains undecided is only his sentence. The state’s requested term has not been imposed.

Guarino says she was at the wedding when her mother called with the news that Ruby had died, hours after the drop-off. “It was the first time we left her there for a sleepover,” she told reporters. “I trusted them. What daughter wouldn’t trust her parents?” The family was told the dog had been attacked by another animal — but when Guarino showed up with local police, she says her parents “turned hostile” and “handed Ruby to us in a box and closed the door.” Investigators sent the dog’s body to the New Jersey Animal Health Diagnostics Laboratory in Trenton, where the necropsy revealed the wound to her face was a gunshot and an X-ray found a bullet lodged in her jawbone; the investigation determined Lentz had shot Ruby in the face, killing her. Lentz was charged on Nov. 3, 2025, arrested at his home without incident, booked into the Ocean County Jail, and released under New Jersey’s bail reform rules while the case proceeded.

At his Nov. 16, 2026 plea hearing before Superior Court Judge Kimarie Rahill, Lentz answered his attorney’s questions under oath: he admitted he was home when the dog was dropped off, had several alcoholic drinks earlier that day, and was carrying a firearm; that he pointed the gun in Ruby’s direction on purpose but intended only to startle her; and that a round went off, struck Ruby, and killed her. Asked whether he never intended to kill or harm Ruby, he replied, “100% correct,” and agreed that pointing a gun to startle the dog was an unlawful purpose and that he handled it recklessly, causing needless mutilation and her death. He pleaded guilty to second-degree possession of a weapon for an unlawful purpose and third-degree animal cruelty; a third count tied to a large-capacity ammunition magazine will be dismissed under the agreement. Why he shot the dog at all is something officials have yet to reveal.

Public Reaction and Consequences

The case drew sustained local attention because of what it meant for the family: Guarino said Ruby had helped her cope with lifelong anxiety — “She was family,” she said. “She was like our child.” Ocean County Prosecutor Bradley D. Billhimer announced the plea and credited the Berkeley Township Police Department and the state diagnostic laboratory for the investigation; Assistant Prosecutor Eleni Demestihas is handling the case. The New York Post pushed the story to a national audience the morning after the plea under the headline framing of a dad who “admits fatally shooting stepdaughter’s French bulldog.” Court coverage of the plea noted that the couple who owned Ruby attended the proceedings still waiting for answers about the dog’s remains — “We still don’t have Ruby,” one section of that account is headlined.

Current Status

Lentz is free on the bail-reform release that followed his Nov. 3, 2025 arrest, awaiting sentencing on Jan. 22, 2027 before Superior Court Judge Guy P. Ryan. The deal, finalized when a trial listing was approaching in January, calls for prosecutors to recommend five years in New Jersey state prison on the weapons count with one year of parole ineligibility under a Graves Act waiver, and a flat three-year term on the animal cruelty count to run at the same time. Under the agreement Lentz will also be banned from owning, harboring or living with any animal and must have no contact with Ruby’s owners, identified in court only by their initials, and the two sides are working out a consent order for selling the guns seized from the home. The proposed sentences and restrictions remain subject to the court’s determination at sentencing.

Impact on Their Career/Life

Lentz’s admission to shooting the puppy entrusted to him now sits on his record as a weapons conviction under New Jersey’s Graves Act and an animal cruelty conviction, with a state prison term of five years sought and, if imposed as recommended, a year behind bars before any parole eligibility. The lifetime animal-ownership ban would bar him from owning, harboring or even living with an animal, and his no-contact obligation formalizes the family rupture — the stepdaughter who said “I trusted them” now appears in his court papers only as an initial. For the family, the plea resolved the question of who killed Ruby but not what they lost: the owners’ account of the plea hearing describes them still waiting for the dog’s remains.

Sources

  • New York Post, “NJ dad admits shooting stepdaughter’s dog in the face while dog-sitting” (Nov. 18, 2026) — source
  • Jersey Shore Online, “Ocean County Man Pleads Guilty In Fatal Shooting Of Dog” (Nov. 2026) — source
  • Shore News Network, “Toms River Man Admits Shooting Year-Old French Bulldog” (Nov. 17, 2026) — source
  • X post, @nypost, Nov. 18, 2026 — source
Page updated: November 18, 2026