Stephen Hutto

Convicted and sentenced. Stephen Hutto, a former pastor in Fountain, Colorado, was convicted by a jury in August 2026 of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old girl and sentenced on Tuesday morning, November 10, 2026, in an El Paso County courtroom to an indeterminate prison term plus six years, with the sentences to run concurrently. The assaults occurred while he worked at Fountain Independent Baptist Church, and he was arrested by Fountain Police in March 2025 while serving as pastor of Highland Baptist Church in Boone. He will spend at least six years in prison, with the Department of Corrections determining the final term on the indeterminate count.

Introduction

Stephen Hutto is a former Colorado pastor whose November 10, 2026 sentencing closed a case that began when Fountain Police arrested him in March 2025 for sexually assaulting a teenage girl from his congregation years earlier. KKTV reported that Hutto will spend at least six years in prison after being found guilty of sexually assaulting a child 16 years before his sentencing.

He was sentenced on two counts. For sex assault on a child by a person in a position of trust with a pattern of abuse, he received an indeterminate sentence, meaning the judge provided a range and the Department of Corrections will make the determination. For sex assault on a child by a person in a position of trust with a victim aged 15 to 18, he received six years. The El Paso County Courthouse said the sentences will be served concurrently.

Background Information

Hutto spent his pastoral career in small Colorado churches. According to KKTV, he was working at Fountain Independent Baptist Church in 2010 when he sexually assaulted a 15-year-old girl, while the Gazette reported that the assault occurred sometime around 2008 or 2009, when Hutto was around 30, and described him as previously a youth pastor at the Fountain church. At the time of his March 2025 arrest, he was the pastor of Highland Baptist Church in Boone, in Pueblo County.

The case surfaced late even by the standards of old abuse claims. According to arrest papers, the incident was not reported until 13 years after it happened, and the call was never forwarded to the appropriate unit for investigation. Hutto was 46 years old at the time his original sentencing hearing was scheduled, according to the Gazette.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Hutto’s August 2026 jury convictions and his November 10, 2026 sentencing are established court outcomes, while the detailed narrative of the assaults rests on his arrest affidavit and trial coverage, and his explanation that the victim invented the allegations out of jealousy remains an assertion he made to investigators.

According to his arrest affidavit as reported by the Gazette, the victim told police she was 15 when she and Hutto started texting back and forth nonstop, that Hutto sent her explicit photos of himself, and that a sexual relationship began after he kissed her. She described several sexual encounters with Hutto across the span of around a year and said they had sex more than 20 times.

Hutto’s own statements to investigators are part of the record. According to arrest papers, he said the victim was jealous of his family because he had been blessed, and that this was why she was claiming he assaulted her. A detective noted that Hutto initially denied ever being alone with the victim in his vehicle, which contradicted a statement he had made to the Pueblo County Sheriff’s Office, and that when told police had obtained the victim’s phone and were downloading the text messages, Hutto’s face became instantly flush and he appeared visibly uncomfortable. Asked whether investigators would find anything inappropriate, he allegedly responded, “I don’t know, um, honestly I texted with a lot of teenagers and stuff,” according to the affidavit.

A jury found Hutto guilty in August 2026 on two counts of sexual assault of a 15-year-old by one in a position of trust. Under Colorado’s sentencing guidelines for crimes of violence, his charges required a mandatory prison sentence with a minimum of 10 years, the Gazette reported before sentencing.

Public Reaction and Consequences

His first scheduled sentencing, on October 6, 2026, had to be postponed. Defense attorney Kevin Flesch requested the continuance, saying Hutto had suffered serious heart problems and a possible stroke that doctors needed more testing to diagnose, and raising concerns that his client would not receive proper treatment at the Colorado Department of Corrections without a diagnosis. 4th Judicial District Judge David Prince granted the request, saying, “I acknowledge the need for the community and for the victims to have this brought to conclusion,” while explaining that in the interest of justice he would not support requiring Mr. Hutto to go to the DOC where he would not receive proper treatment.

As part of the ruling, the judge required Hutto, who was out of custody, to hand over his passport to authorities and told him he could not leave the state. Around 20 supporters, all from the church in Boone, appeared in court that day, and none wished to publicly speak with the Gazette. His mugshot was credited to the Fountain Police Department.

Current Status

Hutto was sentenced on Tuesday morning, November 10, 2026, in an El Paso County courtroom. For the pattern-of-abuse count he received an indeterminate sentence, with the Department of Corrections to determine the term from the range the judge set; for the count involving a victim aged 15 to 18 he received six years. The El Paso County Courthouse said the sentences will run concurrently, so Hutto will spend at least six years in prison.

Impact on Their Career/Life

Hutto’s pastoral career, which ran from a youth pastor role at Fountain Independent Baptist Church to the pulpit of Highland Baptist Church in Boone, ended with his March 2025 arrest and is now compounded by jury convictions for sexual assault committed from a position of trust. Because his sentence on the pattern count is indeterminate, the state rather than a fixed calendar date will decide how long he remains in prison, and his 10-year mandatory minimum under Colorado’s crimes-of-violence guidelines bound the court before it sentenced him.

Sources

  • KKTV, “Former Fountain pastor sentenced for sexual assault on a child” (November 17, 2026) — source
  • The Colorado Springs Gazette, “Former Fountain pastor’s sentencing in child rape case postponed” (October 6, 2026) — source
Page updated: November 10, 2026