Brandy Lovelady Mitchell
Introduction
Brandy Lovelady Mitchell was the deputy superintendent of preK-12 learning and leadership at Grand Rapids Public Schools until November 16, 2026, when the GRPS Board of Education voted unanimously, in a special meeting, to terminate her contract. She had been on paid administrative leave since March 2026, had been hired in 2022, and had twice survived earlier attempts to end her employment. Mitchell denies that the outcome was fair and says the process was fundamentally unfair; she is working with a legal team and pursuing every appropriate avenue to protect her rights and reputation .
Background Information
Mitchell spent nearly 30 years in education, mostly in Grand Rapids. She began her career at Kent County’s Network 180, connecting children and families to mental health and substance abuse services, before moving into public schools as a principal, school counselor, guidance classroom teacher and consultant. District salary data shows she earned $202,743.08 in 2025, making her the third highest-paid district employee. Separately, she has served on the Grand Rapids Community College Board of Trustees since 2020 and was reelected to another term in the November 3, 2026 election .
The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation
Fired after workplace-conduct investigations. This is an employment and leadership-conduct case — no criminal charge is involved. The findings against Mitchell are administrative; she disputes the process and says the investigator did not substantiate several of the allegations .
The road to termination ran through two investigations and two leaves. The first investigation, in 2024, was prompted by complaints from former GRPS communications executive Leon Hendrix, who alleged Mitchell engaged in “disrespectful, demeaning and in some cases intimidating” behavior. An external investigation concluded her conduct did not violate board policy or the law, but found significant conflict with seven employees and described “very low morale” among witnesses. In lieu of termination, Mitchell was placed on an improvement plan — leadership training, professional external consultants, coaching and regular check-ins .
Superintendent Leadriane Roby nonetheless twice recommended the board not renew Mitchell’s contract, citing the 2024 investigation. In a March 12 letter, Roby wrote that the investigation found Mitchell’s “leadership style and interaction with staff had detrimental impact and that her supervisory methods and approach to management created a culture of devaluing members of her staff.” She reported additional complaints after the improvement plan and wrote, “The improvement plan has been unsuccessful.” The board kept Mitchell employed both times; in April 2026 it voted to continue her contract for the 2026-27 school year even as the district launched another investigation into her conduct, and she remained on paid leave through the eight months until the November 16 vote .
Mitchell’s account differs sharply: “After the Board voted in April to renew my contract, the District launched another investigation into the same claims it had already considered,” she said. “I remained on leave for eight months and cooperated fully, and the investigator did not substantiate several of the allegations. The decision came just weeks after the District welcomed a new Superintendent.” District spokesperson Luke Stier declined to share why Mitchell was fired .
Public Reaction and Consequences
Mitchell’s denial is the loudest public response on record: “I strongly disagree with this decision and believe the process was fundamentally unfair,” she told MLive in an emailed statement from her lawyer, adding, “Due process is the standard every public institution must meet. I am working with my legal team and will pursue every appropriate avenue to protect my rights and reputation.” Her attorney, Teresa Caine Bingman, had previously told MLive the district’s investigation was not fair and impartial and that Mitchell did not receive adequate advance notice of the allegations or a meaningful chance to respond .
The consequence is the termination itself — a unanimous board vote ending a roughly $202,000-a-year post after four years in the district’s leadership. The district has said nothing publicly about its reasons beyond confirming the vote .
Current Status
Mitchell was terminated on November 16, 2026 and is signaling litigation: she is working with her legal team to “pursue every appropriate avenue to protect my rights and reputation.” She remains an elected member of the Grand Rapids Community College Board of Trustees, reelected on November 3, 2026 — weeks before her GRPS firing .
Impact on Their Career/Life
Mitchell’s own closing statement framed the stakes: “In nearly 30 years, mostly in Grand Rapids, I have stood for educational excellence, equity, and accountability, and for children and staff whose voices are too often overlooked,” she said. “That has not wavered.” She called the chapter painful but insisted “it will not define my career or my love for public education.” Whether the termination or her legal challenge closes the story, she leaves the district’s second-in-command role with both the investigations’ findings and her denials of them on the record .
Sources
- MLive (Melissa Frick), “GRPS deputy superintendent terminated in unanimous vote” (Nov. 17, 2026) — source