Joseph Eugene Lemay

Convicted and sentenced. Joseph Eugene Lemay, a/k/a “Gene Lemay,” was convicted by a federal jury after a week-long trial in April 2024 and sentenced on November 18, 2026, to 54 months in prison for leading a payroll tax fraud scheme that evaded more than approximately $7.7 million owed to the IRS. The conviction and sentence are established court outcomes; the account of the scheme below is the Justice Department’s summary of the indictment, public filings and evidence presented at trial. Lemay, 65, of Delray Beach, Florida, was also ordered to pay restitution and serve two years of supervised release.

Introduction

Joseph Eugene Lemay is a former moving company president who was sentenced on November 18, 2026, to 54 months in prison for leading a long-running scheme to evade more than approximately $7.7 million in federal payroll taxes owed to the Internal Revenue Service. United States District Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil imposed the sentence in the Southern District of New York, where a jury had convicted Lemay following a week-long trial in April 2024. The scheme targeted payroll taxes owed by a moving and storage business the Justice Department calls Company-1 and affiliated companies, running from about 2010 through December 2016. He was convicted alongside co-conspirator Joel Lingat, who had served as the company’s Head of Accounting.

Background Information

Per the Justice Department’s account, drawn from the indictment, public filings and trial evidence, Lemay was involved in running Company-1 in the 1980s and served as its President from at least the early 2000s through approximately 2010 or 2011. He then became President of an affiliated company while remaining an owner of, and salary recipient from, Company-1. Lingat, 66, of Jersey City, had been Head of Accounting at the company. The release identifies the employer only as a company providing moving and storage services, and it offers no further personal background on Lemay beyond his age and his Florida residence.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Lemay’s case reached a verdict: a federal jury convicted him at trial in April 2024, and the sentence has now been imposed. The scheme described here is the government’s account, reflected in the indictment, public filings and the evidence presented at trial.

From in or about 2010 through in or about December 2016, prosecutors said, Lemay and his co-conspirators — including Lingat — perpetrated a scheme to defraud the U.S. government of payroll and income taxes due and owing to the IRS by Company-1 and affiliated companies. The mechanics, as the release recounts them: the conspirators created at least approximately 23 front companies, nominally owned by close associates or family members of Lemay or others at Company-1; they assigned, on paper only, foremen and movers working for Company-1 to the sham companies; and they fraudulently made it appear the sham companies were independent contractors, including by creating fake invoices by which the sham companies purportedly billed Company-1 for labor.

Because the labor appeared to be performed by independent contractors, Company-1 was able to deduct its cost as an expense on its tax returns without withholding or paying over any payroll taxes to the IRS. In furtherance of the scheme, Lemay directed Lingat’s day-to-day management of bank accounts held in the name of the sham companies and used to pay the foremen and workers in cash — arrangements under which no payroll taxes were withheld on the workers’ behalf. Through the scheme, the department said, Company-1 and affiliated companies evaded in excess of approximately $7.7 million in payroll taxes, including Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) and Medicare contributions, during the charged period.

“Today’s sentence highlights that this Office will not stand by when employers refuse to pay taxes meant to support their workers,” U.S. Attorney Jamie McDonald said in the announcement. “Gene Lemay and his co-conspirators cheated Social Security and Medicare out of millions of dollars, undercutting these important programs that hardworking Americans rely upon at the end of their careers,” McDonald added.

Public Reaction and Consequences

The announcement came as a for-immediate-release press release from the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York dated Wednesday, November 18, 2026, and was republished the same day by EZ News, a justice-news aggregator that classifies DOJ releases with jurisdiction and topic metadata while presenting the official text unchanged. McDonald praised the outstanding work of IRS Criminal Investigation, the investigative arm behind the case. The department’s own headline framed the case as a “multimillion-dollar payroll tax fraud scheme” reaching into the FICA and Medicare contributions owed on behalf of the company’s foremen and movers. No statement from Lemay or his defense was included in the release, and the restitution order — $6,312,560 — stands as the case’s most concrete financial consequence.

Current Status

Lemay, 65, of Delray Beach, Florida, was sentenced on November 18, 2026, to 54 months in prison, to be followed by two years of supervised release, along with $6,312,560 in restitution and a $100 mandatory special assessment, according to the Justice Department. His co-conspirator Lingat, 66, of Jersey City, had previously been sentenced to 24 months in prison, to be followed by two years of supervised release, along with the same $100 mandatory special assessment. The case is being prosecuted by the office’s Complex Frauds and Cybercrime Unit, with Assistant U.S. Attorney Connie L. Dang in charge of the prosecution; the release, numbered 26-331, does not mention an appeal or a report date for the prison term.

Impact on Their Career/Life

At 65, Lemay begins roughly four and a half years in federal prison with a restitution judgment of more than $6.3 million, the capstone of a business career that stretched from running a moving and storage company in the 1980s through its presidency and an ownership stake that outlasted his tenure. Because the fraud was proven at trial, the findings — the front companies, the fake invoices, the cash payroll — are adjudicated outcomes rather than allegations, permanently attaching his name to one of the larger payroll tax evasion cases the Southern District of New York has announced.

Sources

  • U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York, “Former President Of Moving Company Sentenced To 54 Months In Prison For Multimillion-Dollar Payroll Tax Fraud Scheme” (Nov. 18, 2026) — source
  • EZ News, “Former President Of Moving Company Sentenced To 54 Months In Prison For Multimillion-Dollar Payroll Tax Fraud Scheme” (Nov. 18, 2026) — source
Page updated: November 18, 2026