Stephen Kihnley
Fired and defrocked; not charged. Stephen Kihnley was fired as youth pastor at Nashville First Church of the Nazarene and had his Nazarene pastoral license revoked after a former youth group member, now 20, accused him of grooming her, sending sexualized Snapchat messages and touching her inappropriately when she was a minor. Metro Nashville police investigated and presented findings to the district attorney’s office, which said the statute of limitations for sexual battery has passed, so no charge was ever filed. Senior pastor Grant Miller confirmed the firing and license removal, and Kihnley did not respond to WSMV’s requests for comment.
Introduction
Stephen Kihnley is a former youth pastor at Nashville First Church of the Nazarene in Nashville, Tennessee, who was fired and stripped of his pastoral license after a former youth group member accused him of grooming her and touching her inappropriately when she was a minor. WSMV4 Investigates reported the allegations on November 12, 2026: the woman, now 20, says the conduct began when she was 15 and included sexualized Snapchat messages, and she later recovered messages she had saved from ages 14 and 15. Kihnley has not been charged with a crime and did not respond to WSMV’s calls or an attempt to reach him at home.
Background Information
Kihnley led youth ministries at Nashville First Church of the Nazarene, where he actively added and messaged with youth group members on Snapchat — the platform at the center of the allegations. The woman said he initially seemed like a fun, engaged youth pastor. The licensure removal bars him from serving as a pastor anywhere in the Nazarene denomination, and the church’s online staff directory no longer lists him. The case also tested the reach of Tennessee’s Anti-Grooming Act, effective July 1, 2026, which does not apply to earlier conduct.
The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation
What is established: Miller confirmed the firing and license revocation and said Kihnley acknowledged the saved screen captures were legitimate. What is not: no charge was filed, and the touching and grooming allegations are the woman’s account, which Kihnley partly disputes.
The woman told WSMV4 Investigates that Kihnley initially seemed like a fun, engaged youth pastor who messaged youth group members on Snapchat, and that the relationship changed during a game at church when he pulled her against him from behind, rubbed against her and asked whether she liked it. She says she was 15. “There were days where I remember crying myself to sleep because I remember knowing that this is wrong, but I don’t know how it’s wrong,” she said.
She said messages Kihnley sent included “Will you date me?” and “You are an answer to prayer. Love being with you. I love you.” Others, including “Frontals past midnight” and “Lick,” she read as sexual, alongside questions about her menstrual cycle and pictures of him wearing a tank top. Asked whether she was groomed, she said, “One hundred percent. I know that I was.” This summer she confided in church member Janet Killingsworth, who told WSMV, “The first thing she said was, ‘Thank you for opening the door.’”
Killingsworth sent her to Miller, who said Kihnley was fired and his Nazarene pastoral license was taken away. “The behavior was completely inappropriate,” Miller said, describing it as “outside the bounds of what is permissible and allowable and healthy for a pastor and pastoral leadership who’s entrusted with that responsibility.” Miller said Kihnley “disputed the nature and substance of some of the allegations” but “did confirm that the screen captures were legitimate and that the conversation was legitimate” and “recognized the really deep, problematic exchanges that had been taking place and did own up to that.”
After learning of the Anti-Grooming Act, the woman went to police, and a Metro Nashville detective showed her how to recover saved messages from ages 14 and 15. “I knew that they were suspicious and I knew that they were weird,” she said. Police investigated, interviewing Miller, and presented findings to the district attorney’s office, which said the statute of limitations for sexual battery has passed. State Rep. Jody Barrett, a co-sponsor of the law, said it does not apply to earlier conduct. The church also filed a DCS child-abuse hotline report; DCS says it has no active investigation.
Public Reaction and Consequences
The church’s response was swift: Miller confronted Kihnley, the church fired him, the denomination revoked his license, and the congregation barred Snapchat for communicating with youth group members. Killingsworth said seeing the messages made her sick. “This is somebody that we loved and trusted,” she said. The Roys Report and The Nashville Focal amplified WSMV’s reporting, noting none of the coverage said Kihnley is charged with a crime. Asked what she would say to Kihnley now, the woman told WSMV: “I think I would just say, I mean, you didn’t get away with it. Police are still looking into this. People are still talking about it. And that’s on you.”
Current Status
Kihnley remains out of the pulpit but out of court as well. He has not been charged; the district attorney’s office says the statute of limitations for sexual battery has passed, and the Anti-Grooming Act, effective July 1, 2026, cannot reach conduct from years earlier. DCS has no active investigation, and Gallatin police — the woman also spoke with a detective there, since Kihnley lives in the Sumner County town — did not respond to repeated inquiries. The Roys Report, citing a local summary, noted the statute-of-limitations conclusion “does not mean the allegations were adjudicated.” His license is revoked, and the church’s staff directory no longer lists him.
Impact on Their Career/Life
The firing and defrocking ended Kihnley’s ministerial career in the Nazarene denomination, where the licensure removal bars him from serving as a pastor anywhere in the church. He has made no public statement in his own defense, and the allegations now attach to his name through WSMV’s investigation and the outlets that followed it. Within his former congregation, the case left a concrete mark: a social media policy barring Snapchat for youth-group communication. No criminal case will test the allegations in court.
Sources
- WSMV, “Nashville youth pastor fired, loses license after grooming allegations. Here’s what we know” (November 12, 2026) — source
- The Roys Report, “Nashville Nazarene youth pastor fired over claims he groomed teen” (November 18, 2026) — source
- The Nashville Focal, “Nashville Church Fires Youth Pastor Over Grooming Allegations; New State Law Can’t Reach Old Conduct” (November 12, 2026) — source