David Braff

Introduction
David Braff, a former guidance counselor at McKevett Elementary School in Santa Paula, California, now faces trial on charges that he sexually abused 15 students — 13 of them from Santa Paula Unified School District schools — roughly five years after his own district reported him to the state’s teacher licensing agency with detailed allegations, according to an investigation by ProPublica and KQED published November 19, 2026 . The California Commission on Teacher Credentialing never fully investigated the district’s 2019 report and allowed Braff to keep working with children at three more Southern California schools until police arrested him in November 2024 . Braff has pleaded not guilty and has remained behind bars since his arrest .
Background Information
Braff spent four years as a guidance counselor at McKevett Elementary School; the Santa Paula Unified School District recognized him as its employee of the month in 2017, in a photo the district posted to Facebook that shows him holding a certificate bearing his name . In the summer of 2019, at least seven students accused him of inappropriate touching, and Braff resigned midway through the district’s investigation . State law requires districts to report educators who resign after misconduct allegations, and Santa Paula Unified submitted its report to the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing two months after his resignation — a 20-page summary of interviews with the accusers and witnesses that also documented multiple inconsistencies in Braff’s account .
The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation
Charged; awaiting trial. The criminal charges against David Braff are pending in Ventura County: he has been charged with sexually abusing 15 students and has pleaded not guilty, and no count against him has been tried or adjudicated. The 2019 school-district findings described below come from the district’s own report to the state as documented by ProPublica and KQED, not from a criminal verdict. Braff denied the students’ accounts when district administrators questioned him in 2019, and he contends through his not-guilty plea that he did not commit the charged offenses.
The district’s 2019 report to the state alleged a pattern of physical contact with young students. One fifth-grade girl said Braff locked his office door, grabbed her by the hips and forced her onto his lap, and that she cried before counseling sessions and eventually asked to transfer schools to get away from him; two other girls, unaware of each other’s accusations, separately said he touched them near their private parts; and one fourth-grader said Braff had been making her sit on his lap since second grade . When district administrators questioned him during the 2019 investigation, Braff denied touching students near their private parts or having them sit on his lap, saying he only gave students side hugs, high-fives, fist bumps and taps on the knee; he acknowledged touching students on the knee, explaining that he taps a crying student’s knee “to say they are doing a good job to get the sad feelings out,” according to the district’s report .
The state agency that received this report did not act on it. Braff’s case was assigned to a staffer whose job description did not include interviewing victims, and none of the students who came forward was contacted despite the district providing their contact information . In December 2020 the commission’s Committee of Credentials — a volunteer panel that needs only probable cause, a far lower standard than a criminal jury’s — declined to recommend disciplinary action, meaning the full commission never reviewed the case . By then Braff had already spent more than a year as a counselor at a Los Angeles charter elementary school, and he went on to work at three more Southern California schools . After his 2024 arrest, a former student from that charter school told police that Braff had touched the boy’s thigh near his groin during a meeting in his office, according to a court transcript from the criminal case — an allegation Braff has not been tried on .
Police arrested Braff in November 2024, and the state suspended his credentials only after that arrest . He now awaits trial on charges of sexually abusing 15 students .
Public Reaction and Consequences
After the arrest, one parent demanded answers from Santa Paula Unified Superintendent Jeffrey Weinstein, emailing him: “Who dropped the ball and allowed this monster to still be around kids?” Weinstein pointed to the state, saying the district had investigated, handed over all its evidence to the commission and police, and that he “vehemently disagreed” with the agency’s decision not to revoke Braff’s credentials . Nearly two years after the state closed the case, a school administrator reported in 2022 that one of the girls who had accused Braff suffered severe anxiety and could not be in rooms alone with men, and that another had attempted suicide multiple times and spent a year in residential treatment . Commission spokesperson Anita Fitzhugh said credentials are automatically revoked upon conviction for sexual criminal offenses, but that “unless the applicant or educator is convicted of a mandatory criminal offense, there are no written criteria that set the level of adverse action,” adding that “a deep and comprehensive review of the educator discipline system, prioritizing student safety in the schools, is in order” . The same investigation found the commission had likewise let two other reported educators keep working until criminal charges: Brashawn Washington, now serving more than eight years in prison, and Matthew Shelton, convicted of abusing four Benicia students last month .
Current Status
Braff has been in jail since his November 2024 arrest and awaits trial in Ventura County on charges alleging he sexually abused 15 students, 13 of them from Santa Paula Unified schools; he has pleaded not guilty . His credentials are suspended, and he did not respond to a request for comment sent through the Ventura County Sheriff’s Office’s messaging system; his attorney declined to comment to ProPublica and KQED . No count against him has been adjudicated, and the charges remain unproven allegations until a jury or plea decides them .
Impact on Their Career/Life
Braff’s counseling career, once decorated by his district, ended in a jail cell, with the trial ahead of him . The investigation’s broader finding is systemic: because California shows no red flag next to an educator’s name when they resign without state discipline, future employers had no indication of a problem as Braff moved through three more schools, and lawmakers’ attempts to close that gap have failed . His accusers, per the district administrator’s 2022 account, continued to struggle in school and in treatment while he kept working with children .
Sources
- New York Post, “California teacher taught for years after child sex abuse accusations,” November 19, 2026. source
- ProPublica, “This Counselor Faces Trial for Sexually Abusing 15 Students. California Has Been Warned About Him for Years,” November 19, 2026. source
- KQED, “This Counselor Faces Trial for Sexually Abusing 15 Students. California Has Been Warned About Him for Years,” November 19, 2026. source