Desmond Carter

Desmond Carter

Introduction

Desmond Carter, a 21-year-old Baton Rouge man, is scheduled to stand trial on December 7 on first- and third-degree rape charges in the death case of Madison Brooks, a 19-year-old Louisiana State University student who was allegedly raped after a night out near campus in January 2023 and then struck and killed by a car. Carter has pleaded not guilty. His case made news again this week over a pretrial evidence fight: court filings show that after Brooks’ death, Carter — who was 17 at the time — sent a series of text messages telling co-defendants that his mother had warned him not to speak with police, and his defense is fighting to keep those texts out of the trial.

Background Information

According to law enforcement accounts in local reporting, Brooks met Carter, Casen Carver, Kaivon Washington and Everett Lee at Reggie’s Bar in Tigerland, near the Baton Rouge campus, on January 15, 2023. Police say Carver drove the group to a parking lot, where Carter and Washington had sex with Brooks; all three later indicted men maintain the encounters were consensual, while prosecutors allege Brooks, whose blood-alcohol level was measured at .319 percent — nearly four times Louisiana’s adult driving limit — was too intoxicated to legally consent. A coroner’s report said she had physical injuries consistent with rape when she died. The men told officers she then asked to go home, gave multiple wrong addresses and asked to be let out near the Pelican Lakes subdivision, where she wandered onto Burbank Drive in front of a car; the driver stayed on scene and was cleared.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Charged, not convicted — rape trial pending. Carter has pleaded not guilty to first- and third-degree rape; the December trial has not begun, no verdict exists, and what follows are pretrial filings, prosecution allegations and defense claims, not findings of guilt. He is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.

Carter was 17 when he was taken into custody in the case and was later indicted; he is being tried as an adult. Prosecutors allege he sexually assaulted Brooks in the back seat of the car Carver was driving, and Carver is accused of aiding the attack by driving the group and recording the encounter on his phone. The evidence fight now defining the case’s run-up centers on about ten text messages prosecutors say Carter sent in the aftermath of Brooks’ January 2023 death — seven of which, per court filings, referenced his mother’s instruction to stay quiet: “my momma told me don’t say nun,” “my momma told me don’t go to no station or not,” and, explaining her reasoning, “momma said they can’t come talk to me bc i’m underage.” One message appeared to blame co-defendant Casen Carver for cooperating: “facts i don’t wanna talk, but casen gave our names all of us.”

In a September court filing, Carter’s attorney argued that admitting the messages would infringe his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination; prosecutors are fighting to introduce them, and 19th Judicial District Judge Gail Horne Ray has yet to rule on the question. The filing does not differentiate which recipient got which message; Everett Lee, who was arrested but never charged, was also among those Carter texted. At a November 19 hearing, Carter’s attorney Caitlin Fowlkes went further, asking Judge Ray to dismiss the charges outright or exclude evidence — including the texts and video of the night — arguing that publicity around the case, including the “Crime Stories with Nancy Grace” episode posted October 29 in which Grace said of a “sex attack” video, “It’s on video for Pete’s sake. You and I have both seen the video,” had created a “public perception that Mr. Carter is guilty” that no change of venue could fix.

Public Reaction and Consequences

The Nancy Grace episode, which featured Brooks’ mother Ashley Baustert, drew about 156,000 YouTube views in its first two weeks, and Fowlkes told the court the videos Grace described were protected case evidence that, five weeks out from trial, the defense had not seen — suggesting, she argued, they could only have reached the host directly or indirectly through the district attorney’s office. An assistant district attorney countered by pointing to a 2023 press conference at which Carver’s lawyer Joe Long and Ron Haley said they had viewed the footage and believed it would disprove the police’s account. The pretrial fights have been barbed throughout: in September the district attorney’s office moved to hold Carter’s lawyers in contempt over a filing about spectators wearing pink in support of Brooks’ family, arguing the lawyer had illegally disclosed the sex-crime victim’s name rather than her initials. Baustert, for her part, told Fox News Digital her daughter “felt safe that night, she thought these were her friends,” adding that “a lot of selfish choices were made that night, and ultimately it led to a horrific ending.”

Current Status

Judge Ray said at the November 19 hearing she would rule on the dismissal-or-exclusion motion on Monday, November 23, with the trial still set for December 7. Carter had originally been set for trial in August 2026, but prosecutors asked for a continuance days before it was to begin, which the judge granted. His co-defendants’ cases trail his: Carver, charged with principal to first- and third-degree rape and video voyeurism, faces a bench trial on November 30, while Washington, indicted on first-degree rape and video voyeurism counts, has no scheduled trial date. Both maintain the encounters with Brooks were consensual, as does Carter.

Impact on Their Career/Life

Nearly four years after the night Brooks died, Carter — a teenager when he was taken into custody, an adult defendant now — has spent the time in pretrial litigation rather than a resolved verdict: motions in limine, a withdrawn-motions dispute the state resisted, evidence-inspection procedures negotiated among three defense teams, a contempt threat over a name on a filing, and a continuance that reset his own trial date. Long, who represents Carver and sat through the September hearings, framed the stakes bluntly: to prove a principal to rape, “they actually have to prove a rape,” he said — “And Desmond Carter is charged with rape.” Whether the texts stay in, and whether the case survives the Monday ruling, will decide what kind of trial the December date actually holds.

Sources

  • The New York Post, “LSU student Madison Brooks rape suspects want to keep warning texts out of trial,” November 21, 2026 — source
  • Fox News, “Suspect in alleged rape of LSU student killed by car fights to keep mom’s warning texts out of December trial,” November 2026 — source
  • WBRZ, “Judge to rule Monday if charges will be dismissed for man accused of raping Madison Brooks,” November 19, 2026 — source
  • WBRZ, “Trial date for one of three suspects in Madison Brooks rape set for December,” September 17, 2026 — source
  • WAFB, “Judge sets December trial for man accused in Madison Brooks case,” September 17, 2026 — source
  • Daily Express US, “Panicked texts as cheerleader dies falling into traffic after ‘gang rape,’ docs reveal,” November 19, 2026 — source
  • @nypost on X, “Suspect in alleged rape of LSU student killed by car fights to keep mom’s warning texts out of December trial,” November 21, 2026 — source
Page updated: November 20, 2026