Richard Reinaldo Garcia

Introduction

Richard Reinaldo Garcia, a 53-year-old pastor from Arlington, Texas, was convicted by a federal jury on November 19, 2026, of orchestrating a real estate and investment fraud scheme that defrauded more than 70 victims across the United States, Colombia, Mexico, and the Dominican Republic, with collective losses exceeding $6 million. Following a four-day trial before U.S. District Judge Mark T. Pittman, the jury found Garcia guilty of one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and three counts of wire fraud. United States Attorney Ryan Raybould of the Northern District of Texas announced the verdict.

Background Information

According to evidence presented at trial, Garcia and others ran the scheme from at least August 2021 through April 2025, soliciting investor funds for purported “church flipping” real estate ventures and Christian music concert promotions. He promised substantial returns but instead diverted investor funds to personal expenses and business operating costs, and when victims questioned their missing profits, he often falsely claimed their earnings had been reinvested into other projects. The FBI’s Fort Worth Resident Agency investigated the case, which Assistant U.S. Attorneys Mac McDonald and Colin Duffy of the Fort Worth Division prosecuted.

The Controversy or Incident That Led to Their Cancellation

Convicted at trial; sentencing pending. A federal jury found Garcia guilty of wire-fraud conspiracy and three wire-fraud counts after a four-day trial; he faces up to 20 years per count.

Trial evidence showed that Garcia served as a pastor throughout the scheme and used the position to encourage church members to contribute both money and labor toward church-owned real estate projects. Properties were improved with that support and later sold for profit, while Garcia simultaneously solicited additional investments from victims — a closed loop in which the congregation’s wallets and sweat equity financed the exits he controlled.

Prosecutors showed that Garcia controlled multiple accounts connected to church-related entities, including Ministerio Gracia, Iglesia Gracia de Texas, Gracia Church of Texas, and A Pesar de Todo, LLC, and instructed victims to transfer money into those accounts characterized as “donations” to Gracia Church even though the funds were intended as investments tied to the fraudulent scheme. The personal windfall was concrete: between approximately 2023 and October 2025, Garcia directed more than $200,000 annually into his personal bank accounts, drove a 2023 Mercedes electric SUV, and lived in a Mansfield residence that sold for more than $1.6 million.

Public Reaction and Consequences

“This defendant didn’t just take money from his victims,” said U.S. Attorney Ryan Raybould. “He abused personal relationships, exploited the trust people placed in him as a pastor and used false promises to convince victims in the U.S. and abroad to hand over their hard-earned savings. The jury saw through those lies. Today’s verdict delivers accountability for those victims and sends a clear message: fraudsters who exploit trust to steal from others will be prosecuted and held responsible.”

FBI Dallas Special Agent in Charge R. Joseph Rothrock said “the defendant’s scheme betrayed the trust of his congregants and others and used deception to lure them into making investments in his fraudulent projects,” adding that the guilty verdict “reflects the extent to which the defendant jeopardized the victims’ financial security” and that the FBI “remains committed to working alongside our law enforcement partners to protect the public from fraudsters who seek to enrich only themselves.”

Current Status

Garcia stands convicted on all four counts and faces up to 20 years in federal prison on each of them, with sentencing scheduled for March 4, 2027, before Judge Pittman. In the meantime, the FBI is still looking for victims: the bureau has posted an English-language and a Spanish-language “Seeking Victim Information” questionnaire for the Gracia Church / A Pesar de Todo investigation, asking anyone who believes they put money into Garcia’s ventures to come forward.

Impact on Their Career/Life

A pastor’s conviction for defrauding his own congregation — routing investments through church entity accounts, harvesting unpaid labor alongside the money, and dressing investment payments in the language of donations — is as complete a professional destruction as the federal courts can produce. More than 70 victims in four countries lost more than $6 million between them, and the trial record now permanently ties Garcia’s name to a 2023 Mercedes electric SUV, a Mansfield house that sold for more than $1.6 million, and more than $200,000 a year flowing from investor money into personal accounts. When Judge Pittman sentences him on March 4, 2027, each of the four counts carries its own 20-year ceiling.

Sources

Page updated: November 19, 2026